This article examines how food heritage, tourism, commodification and globalisation intersect in northern and north-eastern Jordan, focusing on mansard and Bedouin culinary practices. The study is based on ethnographic participant observation and about 30 semi-structured interviews, for a total of 30 hours of recorded speech. These recordings include oral narratives and life stories collected between 2018 and 2025 in the governorates of al-Mafraq and Irbid. The research sites include a dozen villages along the Syrian border (Sama as-Sirḥān, Zumla as-Sirḥān, Muġayyir as-Sirḥān, Umm al-Guṭṭēn, al-Kōm al-Aḥmar, aṣ-Ṣāliḥiyya, al-Ašrafiyye, al-Bāʿiǧ, Ḥakama, Maru, Saḥam and al-ʿIšše), and interlocutors represent Bedouin tribes, the Druze minority and rural farming communities. Data were collected in local Arabic dialects, fully transcribed, translated into English and analysed through thematic coding and triangulation with official and promotional media (UNESCO, Ministry of Culture, tourism boards) and commercial sources (restaurant menus, online travel agencies, food delivery services). The study traces how everyday foodways have been reconfigured by state discourse, media representation, and tourist demand. Drawing on the concepts of gastronationalism (DESOUCEY 2010), heritage commodification, and staged authenticity (MACCANNELL 1973), the article examines how mansaf has been consolidated as Jordan’s national dish (MASSAD 2001; ALOBEIDAT 2016), asking who gets excluded in the process. Since mansaf’s UNESCO listing in 2022 and ongoing promotion, it has shifted from a regional Bedouin feast to a national symbol, one that official narratives depict as a unifying symbol of Jordanian identity and social cohesion. An analysis of tourism marketing, OTA listings, and curated “Bedouin dinners” reveals front-stage performances designed to satisfy outsiders’ expectations of desert life (zarb ovens, desert camp dinners, and stargazing activities). At the same time, the back regions of everyday culinary practice, such as regional variants and farmers’ and household cuisines, remain unseen and sidelined. Commercial actors and cultural intermediaries (hotels, heritage nonprofits, restaurants) mobilise Bedouin signifiers and mansaf’s simplicity to craft visceral place-based experiences for tourists, often commodifying identity in ways that reinforce existing social hierarchies. Field data highlight local continuities and resistances: many Bedouin informants assert pride in their culinary heritage and retain traditional dishes (rašūf, lazzagiyyāt), while Druze and rural communities emphasise agricultural cuisines and distinct dishes (al-əmraššah, kashkeel, makmūra). Concurrently, globalisation and migration have pluralised everyday diets: Palestinian, Syrian, Gulf and Turkish dishes (falafel, hummus, kabsa, mandi, ouzi) circulate widely, aided by food delivery platforms and restaurant hybridisation. The article concludes that mansaf’s nationalisation exemplifies selective heritage politics: food becomes both an instrument of cultural cohesion and a vehicle for elite economic and symbolic gains, marginalising less marketable regional foodways. Policy implications call for broadening what is recognised and marketed as heritage cuisine: restaurants and tourist facilities could introduce a wider variety of regional dishes alongside their local origins, while international institutions could extend heritage listings to minority and farmers’ cuisines.

From Bedouin Dish to National Symbol: Mansaf and the Making of Jordanian Identity

AL TAWIL M
2026

Abstract

This article examines how food heritage, tourism, commodification and globalisation intersect in northern and north-eastern Jordan, focusing on mansard and Bedouin culinary practices. The study is based on ethnographic participant observation and about 30 semi-structured interviews, for a total of 30 hours of recorded speech. These recordings include oral narratives and life stories collected between 2018 and 2025 in the governorates of al-Mafraq and Irbid. The research sites include a dozen villages along the Syrian border (Sama as-Sirḥān, Zumla as-Sirḥān, Muġayyir as-Sirḥān, Umm al-Guṭṭēn, al-Kōm al-Aḥmar, aṣ-Ṣāliḥiyya, al-Ašrafiyye, al-Bāʿiǧ, Ḥakama, Maru, Saḥam and al-ʿIšše), and interlocutors represent Bedouin tribes, the Druze minority and rural farming communities. Data were collected in local Arabic dialects, fully transcribed, translated into English and analysed through thematic coding and triangulation with official and promotional media (UNESCO, Ministry of Culture, tourism boards) and commercial sources (restaurant menus, online travel agencies, food delivery services). The study traces how everyday foodways have been reconfigured by state discourse, media representation, and tourist demand. Drawing on the concepts of gastronationalism (DESOUCEY 2010), heritage commodification, and staged authenticity (MACCANNELL 1973), the article examines how mansaf has been consolidated as Jordan’s national dish (MASSAD 2001; ALOBEIDAT 2016), asking who gets excluded in the process. Since mansaf’s UNESCO listing in 2022 and ongoing promotion, it has shifted from a regional Bedouin feast to a national symbol, one that official narratives depict as a unifying symbol of Jordanian identity and social cohesion. An analysis of tourism marketing, OTA listings, and curated “Bedouin dinners” reveals front-stage performances designed to satisfy outsiders’ expectations of desert life (zarb ovens, desert camp dinners, and stargazing activities). At the same time, the back regions of everyday culinary practice, such as regional variants and farmers’ and household cuisines, remain unseen and sidelined. Commercial actors and cultural intermediaries (hotels, heritage nonprofits, restaurants) mobilise Bedouin signifiers and mansaf’s simplicity to craft visceral place-based experiences for tourists, often commodifying identity in ways that reinforce existing social hierarchies. Field data highlight local continuities and resistances: many Bedouin informants assert pride in their culinary heritage and retain traditional dishes (rašūf, lazzagiyyāt), while Druze and rural communities emphasise agricultural cuisines and distinct dishes (al-əmraššah, kashkeel, makmūra). Concurrently, globalisation and migration have pluralised everyday diets: Palestinian, Syrian, Gulf and Turkish dishes (falafel, hummus, kabsa, mandi, ouzi) circulate widely, aided by food delivery platforms and restaurant hybridisation. The article concludes that mansaf’s nationalisation exemplifies selective heritage politics: food becomes both an instrument of cultural cohesion and a vehicle for elite economic and symbolic gains, marginalising less marketable regional foodways. Policy implications call for broadening what is recognised and marketed as heritage cuisine: restaurants and tourist facilities could introduce a wider variety of regional dishes alongside their local origins, while international institutions could extend heritage listings to minority and farmers’ cuisines.
2026
13
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
From_Bedouin_Dish_to_National_Symbol_Man.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Versione dell'editore
Licenza: Accesso libero (no vincoli)
Dimensione 235.57 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
235.57 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in ARCA sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10278/5129969
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact