The IFRS has been adopted in 160 jurisdictions globally. Yet, despite this widespread take-up, financial reports following the IFRS are still not fully comparable. Grounded on the new institutional accounting theory, this research aims to investigate the level of harmony between Italian companies implementing the IFRS and to identify whether different accounting policy choices are associated with specific institutional factors. The research sample consists of 856 Italian companies. They are all active Italian firms except banks, financial institutions, and insurance companies that adopted IFRS to prepare their 2022 separate annual financial statement. Italian companies represent an underexplored but valuable field of investigation for the research stream on accounting harmonization since Italy is one of the few countries in the European Union that expanded the adoption of IFRS to unlisted companies and to separate financial statements. To assess the level of harmony between Italian companies in implementing IFRS, we used a selfconstructed list of overt options based on the IFRS adopted in the European Union in 2022. Then, we handpicked data on IFRS policy choices from the 2022 separate annual financial statements of sample companies. Finally, we investigated the level of accounting harmony by analyzing the percentage of sample companies adopting the different accounting options. Using univariate statistics and regression analyses, we also assessed the association between different accounting policy choices and some institutional factors. Our results confirm that the sector and the size of the business strongly influence a company’s IFRS practices – a finding that accords with the extant literature. Further, our study extends to some institutional factors for which limited evidence still exists. Specifically, the type of auditor, the magnitude of the accounting numbers to be reported, and the number of years that a firm has been following the IFRS emerge as factors affecting the IFRS policy choices a firm makes. Instead, IFRS policy choices are not influenced by a company's listing status, nor whether following the IFRS is made mandatory or voluntary. This research provides both theoretical and practical contributions. From the theoretical perspective, we extend the accounting literature on the institutional factors that influence de facto accounting harmonization. From a practical point of view, our findings inform standard setters and IFRS stakeholders (companies, practitioners, report users, capital market participants, etc.) on which IFRS options reduce comparability the most, providing a basis for possible improvements in accounting harmonization policies.

How harmonized is IFRS implementation? Evidence from Italian companies.

Cristina GIANFELICI
2026

Abstract

The IFRS has been adopted in 160 jurisdictions globally. Yet, despite this widespread take-up, financial reports following the IFRS are still not fully comparable. Grounded on the new institutional accounting theory, this research aims to investigate the level of harmony between Italian companies implementing the IFRS and to identify whether different accounting policy choices are associated with specific institutional factors. The research sample consists of 856 Italian companies. They are all active Italian firms except banks, financial institutions, and insurance companies that adopted IFRS to prepare their 2022 separate annual financial statement. Italian companies represent an underexplored but valuable field of investigation for the research stream on accounting harmonization since Italy is one of the few countries in the European Union that expanded the adoption of IFRS to unlisted companies and to separate financial statements. To assess the level of harmony between Italian companies in implementing IFRS, we used a selfconstructed list of overt options based on the IFRS adopted in the European Union in 2022. Then, we handpicked data on IFRS policy choices from the 2022 separate annual financial statements of sample companies. Finally, we investigated the level of accounting harmony by analyzing the percentage of sample companies adopting the different accounting options. Using univariate statistics and regression analyses, we also assessed the association between different accounting policy choices and some institutional factors. Our results confirm that the sector and the size of the business strongly influence a company’s IFRS practices – a finding that accords with the extant literature. Further, our study extends to some institutional factors for which limited evidence still exists. Specifically, the type of auditor, the magnitude of the accounting numbers to be reported, and the number of years that a firm has been following the IFRS emerge as factors affecting the IFRS policy choices a firm makes. Instead, IFRS policy choices are not influenced by a company's listing status, nor whether following the IFRS is made mandatory or voluntary. This research provides both theoretical and practical contributions. From the theoretical perspective, we extend the accounting literature on the institutional factors that influence de facto accounting harmonization. From a practical point of view, our findings inform standard setters and IFRS stakeholders (companies, practitioners, report users, capital market participants, etc.) on which IFRS options reduce comparability the most, providing a basis for possible improvements in accounting harmonization policies.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
4 - Gianfelici.pdf

non disponibili

Descrizione: Contributo
Tipologia: Documento in Post-print
Licenza: Accesso chiuso-personale
Dimensione 838.19 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
838.19 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in ARCA sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10278/5129194
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact