In section 2 I will reconstruct the antirealist motivations of the classic contingentist scenarios developed by James Cushing and by Andrew Pickering; in section 3, by taking into account some versions of scientific realism that are more sophisticated than those discussed by contingentists up to now, I will clarify the logical relations of compatibility and incompatibility existing between contingentism and inevitabilism on the one hand, and scientific realism and antirealism on the other; in Section 4 I will try to spell out the specific contribution of contingentist historical reconstructions to the critique of scientific realism; finally, in Section 5, I will recapitulate the results of the article and argue that the conflict between contingentist antirealism and scientific realism can be seen as a clash of inferences based on interpretations of the history of science. This article will thus consist of a philosophical meta-analysis of a controversy existing between different meta-scientific investigations.
Scientific Realism and the Contingency of the History of Science
Trizio E
2015-01-01
Abstract
In section 2 I will reconstruct the antirealist motivations of the classic contingentist scenarios developed by James Cushing and by Andrew Pickering; in section 3, by taking into account some versions of scientific realism that are more sophisticated than those discussed by contingentists up to now, I will clarify the logical relations of compatibility and incompatibility existing between contingentism and inevitabilism on the one hand, and scientific realism and antirealism on the other; in Section 4 I will try to spell out the specific contribution of contingentist historical reconstructions to the critique of scientific realism; finally, in Section 5, I will recapitulate the results of the article and argue that the conflict between contingentist antirealism and scientific realism can be seen as a clash of inferences based on interpretations of the history of science. This article will thus consist of a philosophical meta-analysis of a controversy existing between different meta-scientific investigations.File | Dimensione | Formato | |
---|---|---|---|
Contingency and realism.pdf
accesso aperto
Descrizione: Bozze
Tipologia:
Documento in Pre-print
Licenza:
Accesso gratuito (solo visione)
Dimensione
206.78 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
206.78 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
I documenti in ARCA sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.